Jonas Brother AMERICAN IDOL JUDGE

no way!! :)

this should be interesting

first!!!!

love the jonas brothers

WOW!

that makes the show a million times better

Ahaa cant wait for the new AI

OMJ now THIS is news Oceanup!! =)

hope its nick. he has the most wisdom :)

NICK FOR SUREEEE!! MOST MUSICALLY TALENTED!! =)

hey!! check out my website cliquegirlzfanwiki.wetpaint.com and follow us on twitter twitter.com/CliqueGirlzWiki

i cant wait but i think its gonna be Nicolas Jerry Jonas:]

nick shouuld:)

it's confirmed that it's joe :D yay!

4?

KEVIN! KEVIN! KEVIN! KEVIN!
i really think he would be a great judge

Its gonna be Nick

Kevins not the singer
Joes got the pretty face and the voice

Nick is the one that can tell what note is what JUST by hearing it

hahaha YAY!
That's awesome.
I hope it's JOE:D

it's not all of them,it's just joe.:(

Haha can't wait.. \

i really think its going to be nick
but i WANT it to be kevin.

Sweet! Definitely watching it!
I hope it's Joseph. I can't get enough of that guy :]

Okay odd... very odd

http://selena-g.us

Sorry, but no way.
Defff Joe.

JOE!!!

Honestly though it should be Nick. love them all but I think he'd be better off judging then Kevin or Joe.

I think either Nick or Joe.
Nick because he's the most musically talented, and Joe because well he's friggin hilarious.
(:
I still love Kevin though, he may even be my favourite. :)

...

i think it should be....JOE!!
JJJOOOOEEEEE!!!!

any of them would be good as a judge but i think joe would be best for it. first of all, i think his reactions would be funny for people that dont sing well...lol :) i can just see joe trying not to laugh at people who suck!! ahahaaaa it would be AWESOME!!

haha, sooooo true

It's Joe.

i think nick...
maybe joe cause his sense of humor would be good for it..
like his facial expressions when some one is horrific.
haha.
but maybe kevin
i dont know!
hahah

http://justjaredjr.buzznet.com/2009/08/18/jonas-brother-to-judge-america...

Nick!

its kinda hard to see them judging people but i think
it will probably be nick

if the jonas brothers can barely sing themselves, why would they want to judge?

I hope its Joe actually.
I want to see his reactions to the horrible singers!
Plus I want to see if anyone auditioning will be all over him lmao!

nick!!!!!!! he should do it. :)

NICK HAAS A BIGGER PART IN CAMP ROCK THIS YEAR ! IT WILL PROBABLY BE KEVIN!

NICK.HAS.NO.TALENT.OKAY? You're brainwashed by his "good looks" to see that he can't sing for crap.

Where???

I have to agree I think Joe's reacting would be hilarious.

it's joe, go to jjj

where is the proof that it's joe?

i think it will be nick :P

NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK

FOLLOW:

@MandyMarlowe

i bet it will be kevin. bc nobody likes him and its just another dissapointment in life. plus he is the easiest to get a hold offfff

nick fo sho'

I thinK JOe!!!....He would be funny at it! :D

nick is the one who study music
so i guess that would be him

it should be all of them!!!
but if its only 1, i think nick would be the best one.
hes the best singer. and hes hot.

ALL OF THEM! THEY ARE THE JONAS BROTHER(S) NOT JONAS BROTHER!

i wish it was nick.

but i already heard that its joe which is totally fine too.

JOE.

does it AIR next week or is it just being filmed??

http://justjaredjr.buzznet.com/2009/08/18/jonas-brother-to-judge-america...

HERE IS THE LINK!!!!!!!

NICK HAAS A BIGGER PART IN CAMP ROCK THIS YEAR ! IT WILL PROBABLY BE KEVIN!--- thats makes so much sense!

Shania Twain?
a Jonas Brother?

YAYYYYY=]

damn justjared confirmed it's joe.... nick would be better though!

check out
http://WWW.LUV2LUVJONAS.COM

if you're a Jonas Brothers fan! :)
Thanks!

Would love to see Demi & Miley as a judge too!

JustJaredJr annouced it was Joe. In my opinion it should be Kevin. There's always buzz around Nick & Joe.

That sounds awesome.
Most likely it will be Nick. haha.

No way. Nick is the most talented. There is no way Joe is more talented than Joe. Nick plays drums, guitar, keyboard. He sings and writes his own songs. He acts. There is no doubt that all three of them are musically (and otherwise) enclined, but Nick tops them all.

That being said, I think it'll be Joe or Kevin, though. Nick seems too young to judge people who are older than him, but I don't know. Nick does seem to be the type to be completely honest. Kevin seems too much of a sweetheart to crush people's dreams. But maybe Joe.

HAHA ITS GONNA BE FRANKIE JONAS!!

Are you kidding me :[[
they should guest judge next season too
I'm auditioning next season since I'm 15 this year..

wow tht interesting i would like to see tht

It shud definetly be nick he wud be the best judge he is soo talented musically :)

IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE
IT'S JOE

LOOK ON JUST JARED JR

I WANT NICK BUT I THINK IT WILL BE JOE

Nick please!!!!!!!!

ITS JOE :D :D :D!!!
YAY!
He's going to be great, lmfao I can't wait to see the episode, too bad its in freaking JANUARY :(

I think that Nick is more talented when it comes to playing the guitar and drums and etc. But I think Joe has the better voice.. But that's just me.

it will be Joe.check justjared.com

Nick or Kevin, I bet :]

Nick IS more talented! Songwriter and everything he plays (instruments) BUT NICKS VOICE IS NOT DOING WELL! ADMIT IT JOES IS MUCH BETTER! NICK IS GOING THRU MAJOR TRAUMA WITH HIS RANGE!

hope its nick. he has the most wisdom :)

______________

i couldn`t agree more.

i don`t think joe would take it seriously. i have a feeling he would be like ellen when she juged 'so you think you can dance' just make a joke out of everything.

&kevin is just too nice to be mean and give critizism. (SP)

hahaaa.(:

It's Joe
Nick is too young to be taken seriously. It's not really Kevin's thing. Plus Joe can handle it more and is the most famous of the 3.

It should definitely be Nick, not because he's my favorite or anything but because he's the main vocals and sings the most and seems to be the head honcho out of the boys and takes things the most serious.

I bet is joe he more outgoing and talks more and they see him as the front man. Joe is the one who they will probably call he will be more honest. Nick gets nervous and shy in front of cameras and kevin wont dare to say anything wrong, so i think joe he more of a dare devil tell all like miley. so i think joe.

Personally, I think Joe is a better singer than Nick (I think Nick strains his voice a lot), but I think overall Nick is more musically talented than Joe, because he can play so many instruments and write songs so well. But whoever says Nick is not talented is lying through their teeth, because he obviously is.

that makes a lot of sense. like i want it to be joe, but i think nick would really be honest to people. i dont think nick would be afraid to tell someone no. kevin would feel too bad and joe would just...idk. haha i just want joe on the show cuz he would be hilarious!

ITS JOE!! ETA: It’s Joe!

TELL JJJ: What do you think of Joe judging the singing comp?

Read more: http://justjaredjr.buzznet.com/2009/08/18/jonas-brother-to-judge-america...

i would like all 3 but yay for whoever it is and i would love to see demi or miley as a judge especially demi love her

YAY! i wish it was all of them!

Its Joe! They're ALL talented though, Nick is just MULTItalented!

WHAT THE FUCK JANUARY??? ahh i cant wait that long :(

THE GUEST JUDGE IS JOE. CHECK JUSTJARED.COM.

This is cool.
Nicholas should, he is more
straightfoward and more talented.
But it's Joe =]
Whateverrr, i'm excited!!!!!!!

nick should be the judge . joe's gonna be the one to be all over the people who audition . player . nick is more mature than joe . and nick CAN SING for shit . he's the one who hits most of the notes .

oh ma gawd!!! NO way! awesomenessss! totally Joe!!!

most likely Nick.
:)

Nick IS more talented! Songwriter and everything he plays (instruments) BUT NICKS VOICE IS NOT DOING WELL! ADMIT IT JOES IS MUCH BETTER! NICK IS GOING THRU MAJOR TRAUMA WITH HIS RANGE!--- heck yeah just listen to Nick on this cover, you ears will bleed warning! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y4M-ltt_2cM

ITS Joe, people

miley and her borthoer are loser

miley wont leave justin alone and trace wont let demi

poor justin he like ingores her annoying ass and demi wow poor girl trace and ugly prick horseface asshole!

it should be nick..

ARUBA

ITS JOE!
why guess when everyone already know that its JONAS JONAS!!!! :)

I really hope it's Joseph <33333

shut up. is this really happening?
and i bet it'd be nick. he's obviously the most talented in the music department. no offense to joe or kevin.
but really i can't picture any of them judging. at all. it's kinda odd.

Nick IS more talented! Songwriter and everything he plays (instruments) BUT NICKS VOICE IS NOT DOING WELL! ADMIT IT JOES IS MUCH BETTER! NICK IS GOING THRU MAJOR TRAUMA WITH HIS RANGE!--- heck yeah just listen to Nick on this cover, you ears will bleed warning! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y4M-ltt_2cM -- No one even clapped for Nick... it was bad..

Dude if they really are going to judge then its going to be nick. No doubt about it.

JOSEPH FOR AMERICAN IDOL JUDGE!!

ITS JOE!
THEY ALREADY SAID IT WAS JOE
JUST JARED JUST SAID IT..

omg yay! love this show :) and now im gunna love it more.

Joe It's confirmed but
I would like to see Kevin there.
Nick is to shy my second option.

No way. Nick is the most talented. There is no way Joe is more talented than Joe. Nick plays drums, guitar, keyboard. He sings and writes his own songs. He acts. There is no doubt that all three of them are musically (and otherwise) enclined, but Nick tops them all.

That being said, I think it'll be Joe or Kevin, though. Nick seems too young to judge people who are older than him, but I don't know. Nick does seem to be the type to be completely honest. Kevin seems too much of a sweetheart to crush people's dreams. But maybe Joe.

---------------

Nick is the most talented eh? You do realize that all three play guitar, drums and piano, right? (Kevin and Joe play bongo drums, weird). Kevin taught himself to play guitar, and proceeded to teach Joe. Nick learned later. The best actor is a tie between Joe and Kevin. Nikc can't sing as well as Joe.

So I guess what I'm saying is that Nick doesn't 'top' his brothers. They're all equally talented. Just saying.

Having said that, I think Kevin would be too "sweet" to be a judge. Nick isn't even an option b/c of his age (you don't take a mediocre, 16 yo talent and have him judge people's musical abilites). The only one left is Joe. I think they chose him because he would be the most available.

Fuck you "fans" make me sick. Get in line with the rest of us and stop trying to force superlatives among them, k?

Its been confirmed that its Joe. So no need to guess anymore.

shut the fuck up. when is joe all over people he doesn't know, in fact, when is joe all over people in general?? he hesitates to hold his own girlfriend's hand in public.

calm down. he'll be funny, he'll make the show much more entertaining, too.

NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!
NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!NICK SHOULD BE THE GUEST JUDGE!!!!!vv

I wanna see what he says about bad singers. That'll be interesting. :)

i really hope it's nick that would be so cool NICK

That's what I meant. I agree Joe is the BETTER singer, BUT Nick is more talented than him because he does such a variety of things.

nick would of been so much better. then joe since he is more of a musician but i forgot its american idol so it doesnt matter.

JOE JONAS IS THE JUDGE ITS CONFIRMED!!!!!JOE JONAS IS THE JUDGE ITS CONFIRMED!!!!!JOE JONAS IS THE JUDGE ITS CONFIRMED!!!!!JOE JONAS IS THE JUDGE ITS CONFIRMED!!!!!JOE JONAS IS THE JUDGE ITS CONFIRMED!!!!!JOE JONAS IS THE JUDGE ITS CONFIRMED!!!!!JOE JONAS IS THE JUDGE ITS CONFIRMED!!!!!JOE JONAS IS THE JUDGE ITS CONFIRMED!!!!!JOE JONAS IS THE JUDGE ITS CONFIRMED!!!!!JOE JONAS IS THE JUDGE ITS CONFIRMED!!!!!JOE JONAS IS THE JUDGE ITS CONFIRMED!!!!!JOE JONAS IS THE JUDGE ITS CONFIRMED!!!!!vv

lets see what he says about bad singers

its joe.
I WISH IT WAS KEVIN !!!!!!!!!!!!
KEVIN KEVIN KEVIN !

That wasn't bad.
I hated how LVATT had Joe and Nick singing the wrong stuff on some songs.
Like in some songs Joe was straining his voice trying to sing high and Nick didn't sound right singing low.
Joe has a smooth deep voice, while Nick has a which sounds better sining higher notes!

aww its joe i wanted it to be nick
kevin would be too nice
nick would have words of wisedom
but i think joe might just tell it as it is
so smart choice

HERES ANOTHER COVER TO 24 JOE SINGS ... PAINFUL! BUT THEY TRY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zVT1l-IYFA4&feature=related

LOVE

oh, okay. then i agree completely :)

Can someone tell me the reasoning they went through to choose Joe?

I mean, why? While they all might be talent, I think Kevin or Nick's clearly has more weight. Therefore they would be better suited to judge someone else's.

That makes absoultely no sense, does it?

JOE MAKES YOUR EARS BLEED HERE.. THE WORST EVER.. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MZnTFD5i7L0

agreed. they need to stick with what they're good at. i love both their voices, but they need to sing what they are good at singing. i also didn't like how pretty much all of lvatt was "nick j feat. kevin and joe".

it'll be nick. i'm pretty sure. but that's awesome, i like that they're having more celebrity guest judges. it makes the show more interesting.
i get so bored watching american idol, though. the only episodes i actually like are the auditions.

HERES ANOTHER COVER TO 24 JOE SINGS ... PAINFUL! BUT THEY TRY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zVT1l-IYFA4&feature=related Joe is bad, but Nick is not great either....

is joe
it said on justjared

AWESOME!!! I think it should be nick

Nick's voice might be in the middle of changing but he still has the best voice. It has texture and isn't nasaly like Joe's. You never know with Joe if he is going to be on key completely on certain notes. And I think Nick does have the most musical knowledge. But since they picked Joe I'm sure it is because he is the most outgoing personality wise. And they only asked a Jonas so they could be assured of ratings during this transition time. It won't make watch the show anymore than I did before, which was never.

WHAT IS IT ABOUT NICK & JOE THAT THEY CAN"T KEEP GIRLFRIENDS? WHEN KEVIN IS SO STABLE...

LEARN TO TYPE U MORON.. Miley's an amzing girl.. but Trace. on the other hand (rools eyes)

Yeah I agree.
Although Turn Right was okay for Joe because the high notes aren't strong high notes.
But yeah like Gotta Find You live is INCREDIBLE because Joe's voice sounds lovely when its sung low.
But when I heard some parts of Poison Ivy and Don't Speak I was like are you kidding me, Joe is STRAINING his precious voice!

thats the reason kevin can stay with a girl. he has more time to give to dani cause he is never the one of the 3 to be asked to do anything. he has all this free time to spend with dani cause joe and nick get all the things to do

WHAT IS IT ABOUT NICK & JOE THAT THEY CAN"T KEEP GIRLFRIENDS? WHEN KEVIN IS SO STABLE... Cause Nick wants a girl in the Music business with Power. Can't get better than the HBIC.. and Joe loves acting. Thats his first love and he wants an actress! I see Nick becoming like a Quincy Jones type! Love to se Joe and Miley in Movie, BUT NOT romanticly. a funny type movie...

Rude. Joe has an awesome voice! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=djHuJ-CoJio

joe has the better voice but lacks technique.
nick has the better technique but worse voice.
it just depends what you care more about to jusge who is the better singer.
:)

man why is it joe ? it should be nick that is lameee

OMG I jsut realized. Simon+Joe+Crazy ass no good singers back talking him= GOLDEN IN RATINGS

This should be a GOOD season ;)

nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick
nick

JOE IS CHARMING BUT NOT A SPEAKER IN ANY WAY SHAPE OF FORM. KEVIN DOES A GREAT JOB AT THAT AS WELL AS NICK!! I REMEMBER IN THE CHAT ONE DAY WHEN JOE DIDN'T KNOW WHAT ON STOOD FOR ! lol ONTARIO & NICK & KEVIN WERE LIKE JOE!!!

stop talking to urself jackie

So after watching the last three weeks of Joe and Stella on Jonas with backup in the form of a few words here and there from the brothers, and then Joe supposedly getting an acting part and this gig, you have to wonder if certain people have forgotten that there are two other Jonas Brothers. And they might actually be more credible in these types of roles. And all of their fans aren't Joe fans and will get tired of following if it becomes Joe and the Jonas Brothers. Just saying...

LOVE FOR MILEY TO BE A GOOD A JUDGE! SHE WOULD GREAT & SO FUNNY!

I'm glad it's not nick he would be to harsh and the auditioners would be like who is this underaged bitch giving judibg my voice talk to me when you hit purberty! I thonkjoe will be good and funny AHHH I can't wait first push now them ahhh

NICK IS SHY IN PERSON... NICK WOULDN'T BE GOOD AT ALL! HE WOULD BE TOO SERIOUS & NOT CHARISMATIC! (LOVE NICK) BUT HES BORING! THATS WHY THE NICKS OF THE WORLD NEED MILEYS!

So after watching the last three weeks of Joe and Stella on Jonas with backup in the form of a few words here and there from the brothers, and then Joe supposedly getting an acting part and this gig, you have to wonder if certain people have forgotten that there are two other Jonas Brothers. And they might actually be more credible in these types of roles. And all of their fans aren't Joe fans and will get tired of following if it becomes Joe and the Jonas Brothers. Just saying...... Joe wants to be an Actor thats HIS PASSION, not Nicks or Kevins.. WHAT THE 3 HAVE TO GO EVERYWHERE TOGETHER & DO EVERYTHING THE SAME?

yeah cause every time nick breaths its for miley

JOEYYYYYY !!! i'm SO proud of him donno why but i had a feeling it was going to be Nick .. i wasn't gonna watch it because there was no Paula but now i am definitely tunning in !! DAMN they sure know how to save a show these producers are fucking smart about the celebrity judges thing

Rude. Joe has an awesome voice! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=djHuJ-CoJio -- YES CAUSE THAT IS IN JOE"S RANGE! I am a singer as well. And I have written a few songs and I KNOW my range..

NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
NICK
I vote Nick! (: <3

Has Kev ever dont anything without Joe and Nick? I know they do events alone, but I dont think I have ever seen Kev do it

sure jackie sure

They already said who the judge is...
its Joe..

Wow.